Skip to content

// analysis

Russia’s shadow fleet: who pays when a tanker runs aground?

Open the documentsThe source documents

The documents cited in the analysis and, where identified, their associated passages. An automatically detected association is not a verified claim.

Consult the references in the article below. No document has been identified for this shortcut.

Illustration for the analysis: Russia’s shadow fleet: who pays when a tanker runs aground?
Sources and reading context

Topics

dated revision: November 20, 2026primary sourcesno tracker
// reading pathAsia in the global financial systemFollow the rates, currencies, credit and capital flows around this analysis.
Contents7 sections

On 17 November 2026, The Maritime Executive reported that unloading had begun on the Caroline Bezengi, aground off Oman since June. As crews worked to recover the cargo, a document published on 6 November had already narrowed the compensation options. The Director of the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds considers that the damage falls within the exclusion for war or hostilities. Several delegations supported that view, subject to new facts emerging. S04 · S05 · S07

After tracing ownership of the tanker Arrow and Lidoil’s bond financing, this instalment examines a different obligation. Who pays after a casualty? A separate case, involving insurer Maritime Mutual, shows how older policies are handled after an insurer stops writing cover. S03 · S17 · S19

Salvage off Oman

The Caroline Bezengi, IMO number 9224439, appears in Britain’s notice of 24 February 2026. A September paper from the Funds places the first report of damage on 8 June, after an explosion thought to have been caused by limpet mines. The tanker later ran aground, and a leak was observed in late June. Accounts differ on the exact day of the grounding. S04 · S16

Oman announced a response on 7 August. On 13 August, Ambrey confirmed it had been engaged to salvage the tanker. On 23 August, Oman’s transport ministry described the ship stranded on rocks near Al Qibliyah and listing by about 17 degrees. The condition of the deck, the lack of power and the sea conditions made the job harder. The November report of unloading marks another stage in the operation. S01 · S02 · S03 · S07

On 13 August, Lloyd’s List reported that AlfaStrakhovanie was understood to be funding the response and that sanctions waivers were needed before salvors could engage. The public summary attributes a financing role to the Russian insurer. The policy, the terms of the waivers and the actual payments remain undocumented in the public material we examined. S06

From certificate to claim

Hull insurance, cargo insurance and cover for liability to third parties address different risks. The last is commonly called P&I, or protection and indemnity. For pollution damage within its scope, the 1992 Civil Liability Convention, or CLC, imposes strict liability on the registered owner, subject to the convention’s exceptions. A ship carrying more than 2,000 tonnes of oil in bulk as cargo must have insurance or other financial security. That cargo threshold is distinct from the gross tonnage used to calculate the liability limit. S08 · S09 · S10

The insurer typically issues a blue card confirming cover. The competent state reviews the security and issues or certifies the CLC certificate, which the ship must carry. The International Maritime Organization recommends examining the guarantor’s financial strength and reinsurance. Denmark specifies the evidence it requires from an insurer outside the International Group of P&I Clubs, including authorisation and reinsurance records and an external auditor’s statement. The Funds’ guidance calls for a prompt review of the insurance and the insurer’s finances after an incident. S08 · S12 · S13 · S14

From certificate to compensation Before an incident, the insurer supplies a Blue Card, the competent State issues a CLC certificate and the ship presents it for inspection. After an incident, victims may bring a direct claim against the insurer or guarantor. Cover depends on the cause, territory and admissible damage. Certification and compensation are separate processes. {"publisher": "l0g", "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "cutoff": "2026-11-19", "language": "en", "chart": "certificat", "unit": "Qualitative certification and direct-action pathways; unscaled arrows", "period": "Convention framework and public administrative guidance checked2026-11-19", "limits": "Illustrative legal mechanism, not the certificate or policy of a named ship. A state certificate is distinct from a state guarantee to pay. Direct action and compensation remain subject to treaty scope and admissibility.", "sources": [{"id": "S08", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Text-of-Conventions_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S13", "url": "https://www.dma.dk/ship-survey-and-registration/apply-for-a-certificate"}]} From certificate to compensation Two procedures. One pollution risk. 01 / BEFORE AN INCIDENT Insurer Competent State Ship / inspection Blue Card CLC certificate Undertaking to cover Statutory certification Evidence carried on board 02 / AFTER AN INCIDENT Assessing cover Cause Territory Admissible damage Victims Insurer / guarantor Direct action A claim against the insurer or guarantor Compensation, where payable
From certificate to compensation Before an incident, the insurer supplies a Blue Card, the competent State issues a CLC certificate and the ship presents it for inspection. After an incident, victims may bring a direct claim against the insurer or guarantor. Cover depends on the cause, territory and admissible damage. Certification and compensation are separate processes. {"publisher": "l0g", "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "cutoff": "2026-11-19", "language": "en", "chart": "certificat", "unit": "Qualitative certification and direct-action pathways; unscaled arrows", "period": "Convention framework and public administrative guidance checked2026-11-19", "limits": "Illustrative legal mechanism, not the certificate or policy of a named ship. A state certificate is distinct from a state guarantee to pay. Direct action and compensation remain subject to treaty scope and admissibility.", "sources": [{"id": "S08", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Text-of-Conventions_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S13", "url": "https://www.dma.dk/ship-survey-and-registration/apply-for-a-certificate"}]} From certificate to compensation 01 / BEFORE AN INCIDENT Insurer Blue Card: undertaking to cover Competent State Issues the CLC certificate Ship / inspection Certificate presented on board 02 / AFTER AN INCIDENT Assessing cover Cause · territory · admissible damage Direct action Victims Insurer or guarantor Compensation, where payable
FIG. 01The Blue Card records the insurer’s or guarantor’s undertaking, on which the competent State bases its CLC certificate. After damage occurs, the convention provides for direct action against the insurer or guarantor, with defined defences.Sources: 1992 CLC, Article VII · Danish Maritime Authority, issuing certificates.The general framework of the 1992 CLC, Article VII. Checking a certificate and assessing a compensation claim involve distinct procedures. The diagram shows generic roles.

The convention lets victims bring a claim directly against the insurer or guarantor. It limits the defences available. The owner’s bankruptcy alone, for example, is unavailable as an insurer’s defence. Payment still depends on recognition of the claim and the guarantor’s ability to meet it. S08

How the owner and the Funds share costs

The CLC scale starts at 4.51 million special drawing rights (SDR) up to 5,000 gross tonnage units. It rises by 631 SDR per additional unit to a maximum of 89.77 million SDR. The 1992 Fund can cover eligible damage when CLC protection is inadequate, including when the owner and guarantor cannot meet the claims financially. Its 203 million SDR event limit includes amounts paid under the CLC. S08 · S09 · S25

Oman is a member of the 1992 Fund. France also belongs to the Supplementary Fund, with a total ceiling of 750 million SDR, inclusive of the preceding tiers. These limits apply to eligible damage within the relevant territory. The Funds draw most contributions from receivers whose qualifying oil receipts exceed the convention’s threshold of 150,000 tonnes in a calendar year. Pooling costs this way can shift part of a spill’s burden to companies receiving oil elsewhere. S11 · S23 · S25

How far compensation can reach Three bars with a common zero origin and scale show the maximum CLC liability schedule, SDR 89.77 million, CLC plus the 1992 Fund, SDR 203 million, and the combined total including the Supplementary Fund, SDR 750 million. The CLC limit depends on gross tonnage. Admissibility and exclusions, including war and hostilities, are considered before these ceilings. For admissible damage within their territories, Oman is a 1992 Fund member and France is also a Supplementary Fund member. These values are neither assessed losses nor payments for Caroline Bezengi. {"publisher": "l0g", "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "cutoff": "2026-11-19", "language": "en", "chart": "plafonds", "unit": "Million Special Drawing Rights (SDR); cumulative statutory compensation limits per incident", "period": "Current limits and country status checked2026-11-19", "limits": "CLC89.77 is the maximum of a gross-tonnage-based scale, not every ship limit.203 includes CLC payments;750 includes CLC and1992Fund. Common zero and linear scale. Territory and admissibility apply. No valuation or available compensation for CarolineBezengi.", "sources": [{"id": "S05", "url": "https://documentservices.iopcfunds.org/download/85381/en/IOPC-OCT26-11-2_en.pdf"}, {"id": "S08", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Text-of-Conventions_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S10", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/ITOPF-IG-IOPC-Compensation-booklet_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S11", "url": "https://documentservices.iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2026/01/2026-1_ratifications_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S25", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/about-us/legal-framework/1992-fund-convention-supplementary-fund-protocol/"}]} Compensation ceilings Per-incident ceilings · million SDR Eligibility of damage War / hostilities exclusions The damage, location and cause determine access to the compensation regime. 0 250 500 750 CLC Schedule maximum 89.77 1992 Fund Including CLC 203 Supplementary Fund CLC + 1992 Fund 750 Territorial examples, subject to eligibility OMAN 1992 Fund SDR 203M FRANCE Supplementary Fund SDR 750M
How far compensation can reach Three bars with a common zero origin and scale show the maximum CLC liability schedule, SDR 89.77 million, CLC plus the 1992 Fund, SDR 203 million, and the combined total including the Supplementary Fund, SDR 750 million. The CLC limit depends on gross tonnage. Admissibility and exclusions, including war and hostilities, are considered before these ceilings. For admissible damage within their territories, Oman is a 1992 Fund member and France is also a Supplementary Fund member. These values are neither assessed losses nor payments for Caroline Bezengi. {"publisher": "l0g", "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "cutoff": "2026-11-19", "language": "en", "chart": "plafonds", "unit": "Million Special Drawing Rights (SDR); cumulative statutory compensation limits per incident", "period": "Current limits and country status checked2026-11-19", "limits": "CLC89.77 is the maximum of a gross-tonnage-based scale, not every ship limit.203 includes CLC payments;750 includes CLC and1992Fund. Common zero and linear scale. Territory and admissibility apply. No valuation or available compensation for CarolineBezengi.", "sources": [{"id": "S05", "url": "https://documentservices.iopcfunds.org/download/85381/en/IOPC-OCT26-11-2_en.pdf"}, {"id": "S08", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Text-of-Conventions_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S10", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/ITOPF-IG-IOPC-Compensation-booklet_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S11", "url": "https://documentservices.iopcfunds.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2026/01/2026-1_ratifications_e.pdf"}, {"id": "S25", "url": "https://iopcfunds.org/about-us/legal-framework/1992-fund-convention-supplementary-fund-protocol/"}]} Compensation ceilings Per-incident ceilings · million SDR Eligibility of damage The damage, location and cause determine access to the regime. War / hostilities exclusions 0 250 500 750 CLC Schedule maximum 89.77 1992 Fund Including CLC 203 Supplementary Fund CLC + 1992 Fund 750 OMAN SDR 203M FRANCE SDR 750M Relevant territory · admissible damage
FIG. 02These are inclusive totals per incident: SDR 203 million includes CLC payments, while SDR 750 million also includes the 1992 Fund. The maximum on the CLC tonnage schedule is SDR 89.77 million.Sources: convention texts · CLC schedule · Fund ceilings · States parties.The general framework is subject to the conventions’ eligibility, causation and territorial requirements. A vessel’s CLC limit depends on gross tonnage. The Oman and France examples concern where admissible damage occurs, including the maritime extensions provided by the conventions. A vessel’s flag alone does not establish access to the Funds.

The cause of the damage shapes access to the Fund

Article 4 of the Fund Convention excludes damage when the Fund proves that it resulted from an act of war, hostilities, civil war or insurrection. The CLC provides a corresponding defence for the owner and insurer. In the Oman case, the Director links the grounding and spill to the damage attributed to the mines. Ghana asked for careful consideration of the nature of the attack and its link to hostilities. The view recorded by the Funds concerns the 1992 Fund’s own obligations on the evidence available at the time. S04 · S05 · S08

The International Group told the Funds that war risks are normally covered separately from ordinary P&I. Identifying anyone liable to pay under war cover would require the applicable policy for the Caroline Bezengi, if any, including its dates and exclusions. That question remains open. S05

Maritime Mutual’s older contracts

Britain designated its New Zealand and Gibraltar entities on 24 February 2026. On 3 March, Belize’s maritime administration removed the New Zealand insurer from its approved list and required replacement cover for affected vessels. On 5 June, New Zealand’s central bank said the insurer had reported a wind-down and termination of its cover. It revoked an exemption concerning use of the word insurance in the company’s name. The central bank says the company operated as an unlicensed insurer in New Zealand and served customers outside the country. S15 · S16 · S17 · S18

On 7 October 2026, the UK’s Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation extended and expanded a licence allowing certain payments connected to written contracts predating the designations. The conditions depend on the counterparty and purpose of the payment. The licence is scheduled to expire on 6 October 2027, subject to amendment or revocation. Designated entities relying on it must report their activities within 14 days after each month ends. Those reports could connect the permissions in the licence to payments actually made under older contracts. S19 · S20

Scope of the investigation

This article uses documents consulted by 20 November 2026. The status of unloading comes from the 17 November report. The individual certificate, policies, payment records and salvage bills for the Caroline Bezengi remain outstanding. The conventions set the limits of separate compensation regimes. We conducted no interviews with the salvors or insurers for this article. The cover image is an AI-generated illustration.

Sources

  1. S01 · Oman MTCIT / Environment Authority · Published: 2026-08-07 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Oman: response to the grounded tanker
    Passages and scope

    Joint release body. Official response announcement; no policy, invoice or indemnity disclosed.

  2. S02 · Oman MTCIT · Published: 2026-08-23 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Oman: the practical constraints of the Caroline Bezengi response
    Passages and scope

    Statements by Mohammed bin Abdullah Al-Rawahi; list, power supply, rocky seabed and contractors. Coordinating ministry release. Approximately 17-degree list at this stage; no cost breakdown. An earlier ONA dispatch has the same title; publication dates differ.

  3. S03 · Ambrey · Published: 2026-08-13 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Ambrey: engagement in the salvage operation
    Passages and scope

    Opening paragraphs and photograph caption. First-party statement: mobilisation, specialists aboard and support vessels en route. The 6 August photograph does not date the grounding. No payer identified.

  4. S04 · IOPC Funds Secretariat · Published: 2026-09-22 · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: preparatory paper on geopolitical events
    Passages and scope

    IOPC/OCT26/4/3, PDF pp. 2–3. Secretariat analysis; explosion, grounding and pollution sequence. Distinguishes sanctions-related payment obstacles from war exclusion. Attacker not established.

  5. S05 · IOPC Funds · Published: 2026-11-06 · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: final record of the October 2026 sessions
    Passages and scope

    IOPC/OCT26/11/2, PDF pp. 25–28, sections 4.6.3 and 4.6.10–19. Several delegations support the Director’s war-exclusion view for Caroline Bezengi on available evidence, unless new facts emerge. Includes Ghana and International Group interventions. No court judgment or payment established.

  6. S06 · Lloyd’s List / Richard Meade · Published: 2026-08-13 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Lloyd’s List: reported financing of the salvage response
    Passages and scope

    Public summary of 13 August. It attributes a financing role to AlfaStrakhovanie and reports waivers. The summary supplies neither a contract nor the waiver references.

  7. S07 · The Maritime Executive · Published: 2026-11-17 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Offloading reported on 17 November
    Passages and scope

    First two paragraphs; SS Navigator alongside. Latest operational report located. Specialist-press observation without an official transferred-volume or compensation tally. Speculation about transfer to a third ship is excluded.

  8. S08 · IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20Texts of the liability and Fund conventions
    Passages and scope

    CLC Articles I–III, V and VII: PDF pp. 4–7; Fund Articles 4 and 9–12: pp. 13–15; Supplementary Protocol Articles 4, 10 and 14: pp. 24–26. Legal texts: security, direct action, limits, exclusions, prevention and contributions. Exact formula retained; institutional 140,000 GT shorthand is not used as an exact arithmetic endpoint.

  9. S09 · IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: current explanation of the 1992 CLC
    Passages and scope

    Liability, limits table, insurance and direct action. Current institutional explanation. Cargo threshold above 2,000 metric tonnes; limits depend on gross tonnage. Liability and defences read with treaty text.

  10. S10 · ITOPF / International Group / IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20Oil pollution compensation guide
    Passages and scope

    Sections on compensation arrangements, liabilities and conventions; PDF pp. 20–21 for Bunkers. Joint institutional and industry guide. Explains separate liabilities and regimes; proves no policy applicable to Caroline Bezengi.

  11. S11 · IOPC Funds · Published: 2026-01-06 · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: states party to the conventions
    Passages and scope

    IOPC/2026/Circ.1, PDF pp. 2–3; Oman and France entries. Oman: 1992 Fund; France: 1992 Fund and Supplementary Fund. No global member count used: dynamic list also contains future membership dates.

  12. S12 · International Maritime Organization · Published: 2024-06-20 · Accessed: 2026-11-20IMO: examining insurance certificates and providers
    Passages and scope

    Annex: provider assessment, financial capacity, reinsurance and periodic review. Implementation guidelines; recommended assessment criteria are distinct from newly created treaty obligations.

  13. S13 · Danish Maritime Authority · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20Denmark: issuing insurance certificates
    Passages and scope

    CLC certificate section: Blue Card and requirements for insurers outside the International Group. Danish administrative practice: insurer’s undertaking followed by a state certificate; authorisation, reinsurance and auditor statements. Does not imply a state budget guarantee.

  14. S14 · IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: guidance to Member States on claims handling
    Passages and scope

    Section 14, Other insurers, paragraphs 14.1–14.3. Post-incident checks of financial standing, solvency and policy scope; cooperation with commercial insurers is contemplated.

  15. S15 · Reserve Bank of New Zealand · Published: 2026-06-05 · Accessed: 2026-11-20RBNZ: Maritime Mutual’s prudential status
    Passages and scope

    Paragraphs on licensing, supervision and name exemption. No New Zealand prudential licence; products unavailable to people in New Zealand. Name exemption distinct from prudential authorisation. No finding of insolvency.

  16. S16 · UK FCDO · Published: 2026-02-24 · Accessed: 2026-11-20United Kingdom: designations of 24 February 2026
    Passages and scope

    Caroline Bezengi: PDF pp. 145–146, RUS3341; MM NZ: p. 268, RUS3466; MM Gibraltar: pp. 273–274, RUS3472. Evidence of administrative decisions, with reasons attributed to UK authorities. IMO 9224439 identity; historical flag data. No judicial guilt finding or payment established.

  17. S17 · Reserve Bank of New Zealand · Published: 2026-06-05 · Accessed: 2026-11-20RBNZ: revocation of Maritime Mutual’s exemption
    Passages and scope

    PDF p. 1, sections 3–4(b), p. 2 section 4(c); earlier notices appended. Reports confirmation of wind-down, termination of coverage and cessation of insurance offers after sanctions. Concerns the name exemption; no finding that all past liabilities are extinguished.

  18. S18 · International Merchant Marine Registry of Belize · Published: 2026-03-03 · Accessed: 2026-11-20Belize: removal of Maritime Mutual from the P&I list
    Passages and scope

    IMM-045(26), PDF p. 1. Approval withdrawal for Belize-flag ships. Compliance by each operator with the replacement requirement was not checked.

  19. S19 · OFSI / HM Treasury · Published: 2026-10-07 · Accessed: 2026-11-20OFSI: licence for winding down prior Maritime Mutual contracts
    Passages and scope

    INT/2026/8893924, PDF pp. 1–3: definitions, sections 4.1–4.7, 6 and 9–10. Conditional permission for certain transfers under written contracts before 24 February 2026; includes monthly reporting. Legal permission distinct from observed transfers. Revocable.

  20. S20 · OFSI / HM Treasury · Published: 2026-10-07 · Accessed: 2026-11-20OFSI: notice explaining the 7 October amendment
    Passages and scope

    PDF pp. 2–3, chronology and Qualifying Overseas Wind-down Payment. Explains qualifying payments under certain contracts outside the UK insurer/broker branch and the 6 October 2027 expiry. Publishes no payment reports.

  21. S23 · IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: oil receivers, contributions and payments
    Passages and scope

    Who pays?; How are contributions calculated?; What are the levies for? Annual threshold above 150,000 tonnes of contributing oil. Supplementary Fund: one-million-tonne minimum per state. No current Caroline Bezengi cost inferred.

  22. S25 · IOPC Funds · Published: not stated · Accessed: 2026-11-20IOPC Funds: limits and conditions of both Funds
    Passages and scope

    1992 Fund and Supplementary Fund sections; compensation limits. Current cumulative limits of SDR 203m and SDR 750m. Fund may intervene when owner and guarantor cannot satisfy admissible claims. Prior payments are included.

This analysis is not investment advice.

// cite this analysis

l0g, “Russia’s shadow fleet: who pays when a tanker runs aground?”, l0g.fr, published November 20, 2026, updated November 20, 2026, https://l0g.fr/en/analysis/shadow-fleet-tanker-insurance-compensation/


$ cd ../analysis